Design/Whiteboards/Badges

    From The Document Foundation Wiki

    Summary

    Would it be good for TDF Members to have a badge they can display on their home pages? And could there be some other badges to display the contributions and so the meritocraty? As it is a strategy to give all contributors an appreciation such badges could be part of it.

    The badges can be used on

    Status

    Analysis Call for Proposals Shaping Tentative Design Blueprint Implemented

    Scope

    In Scope Out of Scope
    • discussion about using and awarding

    Discussion

    Time

    • Collecting proposals: 14th June 2013
    • Voting for proposals on ml: 28th June 2013

    Proposals

    Proposal by User:k-j

    Mockups

    Example for
    Credit badges members all proposal k-j.png Credit badges design all proposal k-j.png Credit badges developer all proposal k-j.png Credit badges l10n all proposal k-j.png Credit badges docu all proposal k-j.png Credit badges QA all proposal k-j.png Credit badges web all proposal k-j.png Credit badges projects all proposal k-j.png Credit badges libOx all proposal k-j.png Credit badges marketing all proposal k-j.png
    Members badge Design badge Developer badge Language (l10n) badge Documentation badge QA badge Website badge Projects badge LibOx badge Marketing badge


    And with text:

    Badge cm 01.png|Badge design 01.png|Badge cD 01.png


    Using valuation:

    Badges design value 01.png

    Getting the svg with green labels:

    Badge green.svg

    Certified Developers
    Badge for
    Badge cD green01.png Badge cD olive01.png
    1st proposal with green colour 1st proposal with 4.0-olive colour

    Description

    First proposal based on Nik's proposal 4,5

    The valuation (gold, silver, bronze) should be done by some defined criteria for every project, based on strengthness and duration of contributions. "Quality" shouldn't be a criteria, because most of quality isn't valuable. Maybe the badges will be awarded by the MC. But this is not part of this Whiteboard.

    Levels could create a bit of a chasm between contributors. Project-internally it might be a good/useful metric, especially for developers/deciders looking to see who to trust from us more, who to maybe be a bit more careful about. Obviously, it is not completely objective ... but that should be not a huge problem. We could maybe rename the categories to roughly One-Time/Sustained/ Current Activity. (Thanks to Stefan for this points to think of).

    E.g.:

    Wiki contributions:
    up to 20 -> green
    up to 100 -> bronze
    up to 1000 -> silver
    above 1000 -> gold

    Proposal by NN

    Mockups

    Description

    Adding proposals

    Each designer should be able to add his proposal under the "Proposals" category.